2 weeks Ago
Patna-based educator and popular YouTuber Faisal Khan , known widely as Khan Sir , has sparked a wave of criticism after delivering an erroneous explanation about the roles of Cabinet Ministers, Ministers of State, and Ministers of State (Independent Charge). His inaccurate breakdown of these positions led to backlash, with some accusing him of routinely spreading misinformation in his lessons. Critics labeled him a "scam," asserting that his meteoric rise during the COVID-19 pandemic was fueled by a robust public relations campaign.
The Controversial Video The contentious video, recorded five years ago and hosted on his YouTube channel Khan GS Research Centre, resurfaced online, showcasing his explanation of the distinctions between these ministerial roles. Khan Sir claimed, “A Minister of State cannot make independent decisions. However, if the Cabinet Minister is unavailable, the Minister of State temporarily assumes responsibility for the department.
During this period, they act as the head and are referred to as having Independent Charge." He added, “While holding Independent Charge, the Minister of State can operate autonomously, but once the Cabinet Minister returns, the designation reverts to Minister of State. At any given time, the role can only be one of the two—either Minister of State or Minister of State with Independent Charge.
When the Cabinet Minister is present, it’s the former; when absent, it becomes the latter.” To make the concept relatable, Khan Sir humorously likened it to a household scenario where a husband temporarily takes charge during his wife’s visit to her parental home, relinquishing control upon her return. Reactions on Social Media The video ignited debates online, with a user on X (formerly Twitter) remarking: “Your name is Khan Sir, and some even call you a map expert.
From teaching railway gatekeeper courses to ambassadorial coaching, your branding during the pandemic made you a nationwide sensation.” — khurpenchh (@khurpenchh) The same user continued, “You once claimed to receive a Rs 107-crore offer, yet you transitioned from teaching Group D aspirants to conducting UPSC and BPSC mock interviews. After watching this video, any serious government exam student would find your explanation ridiculous.
” Where Did Khan Sir Go Wrong? To clarify, Ministers of State can independently handle responsibilities within their assigned purview but typically require Cabinet approval for significant policy decisions. A Minister of State with Independent Charge, however, manages a department autonomously, akin to a Cabinet Minister within defined limits. The two roles are fundamentally distinct and can coexist.
Who Is Khan Sir? Faisal Khan, celebrated for his engaging teaching style, has amassed a large following among students preparing for government jobs. His YouTube channel, Khan GS Research Centre, boasts a massive subscriber base of 21.3 million.
Despite his success, Khan Sir’s journey has been fraught with challenges, as he shared in an interview with The Lallantop. He revealed that after gaining initial popularity, certain individuals attempted to unlawfully take over his coaching center. Disheartened but determined, he started afresh with help from former students.
His troubles didn’t end there—his new center was even attacked with bombs by individuals angry over his affordable fees for UPSC aspirants. Khan Sir persevered and rose to prominence during the pandemic by leveraging online platforms to reach a broader audience. Reports estimate his monthly earnings from YouTube at Rs 10–12 lakh, with a net worth of approximately Rs 5 crore.
.
