The ‘Most Underrated’ Makeup Products Better Than Urban Decay and Glossier Products up to 4x the Price, According to Real Women

'Tried and tested' products that shouldn't be overlooked.

featured-image

Between TikTok ads and influencers sharing new makeup products every day, it’s easy to be inundated with the most popular brands and think those are the best of the best. Sure, some high-quality makeup brands are worth the hype, but just because something is more expensive doesn’t necessarily mean that it's superior. And sometimes, with all the noise online, it can be easy to overlook beauty products that are just as good (or better) and a fraction of the price.

So what are some of the most underrated makeup products? According to real women on Reddit, one is a setting spray and another is brow gel by two different value makeup brands that shouldn’t be ignored. Parade aims to feature only the best products and services. If you buy something via one of our links, we may earn a commission.



Related: 10 Best Contour Sticks for Mature Skin, According to Professional Makeup Artists The Most Underrated Makeup Products, According to Real Women At the end of October, one user on the subreddit page, r/Makeup , posted a question asking for "underdog" products people recommend. “Makeup products that you find underrated that are amazing?” they titled their post. “I saw a thread in here last night about overrated and unappealing makeup, and it got me thinking about the opposite,” they wrote.

“What are everyone's go to, holy grail, tried and tested 'wow' products?” Whether you use makeup all of the time or you’re a beginner, it’s always helpful to hear other people’s favorite products, especially if they’re “underrated.” It can help step up your makeup game while maybe even saving you money. And some of the responses on this post have us clicking "add to cart.

" 🛒🛒 SIGN UP for our Pop Shop newsletter & get the best deals, problem-solving products & cool finds right in your inbox 🛍️ Wet n Wild Photo Focus 24-Hour Setting Mist - 2.2 fl oz, $6.39 at Target Target "Anything from Wetnwild,” one user wrote in one of the most-liked comments.

“I love their photo-focused foundation and their liquid catsuit lipsticks. WetnWild also has really pigmented eyeshadow and their 24-hour setting is better than urban decay all nighter." Another person agreed and commented, "They have really stepped up their game.

They used to be the lowest end of the low." Related: Nordstrom's Limited-Time Beauty Sale Includes Major Brands at Up To 40% Off — Shop Our 9 Picks Before They're Gone Urban Decay Travel Size All Nighter Waterproof Makeup Setting Spray , $17 at Ulta Beauty Ulta Beauty Wet n Wild Photo Focus 24-Hour Setting Mist comes in a 2.2 fl oz bottle for $6.

39 at Target and comes in both matte and finishes. It’s marketed as lightweight and offers 24-hour wear when you spray it over your finished makeup whether it’s for “work, play or party..

.” In comparison to, Urban Decay’s All Nighter Waterproof Setting Spray costs $17 for their travel size, which is 1 oz at Ulta Beauty. This setting spray is a well-known classic and must-have for many makeup lovers out there.

It’s marketed as keeping “makeup fresh, smudge-proof and transfer-resistant for up to 16 hours.” e.l.

f. Wow Eyebrow Enhancer Gel - 0.12oz, $5 at Target Target Another "underrated" product that was shared in this Reddit post in comparison to another, higher-end brand is the e.

l.f. Wow Eyebrow Gel , which is $5 for a 0.

12 oz tube at Target. Whether you have thin eyebrows or not, this buildable brow gel helps define the hair more and create a really full look. “Love this because it is buildable but not heavy and also colors the stray grays so I don't want to yank them out,” one commenter wrote.

“Small learning curve but gets the job done.” Another user agreed, writing, ”I picked up a Glossier boy brow and honestly, no reason not to just stick with ELF.” Related: 7 Reasons To Add Aloe Vera to Your Skincare Over 50, According to Dermatologists Boy Brow Grooming pomade , $22 at Glossier Glossier Glossier’s Boy Brow is $22 for a 0.

13 oz tube and offers the same result as e.l.f.

’s; “Boy Brow visibly defines, thickens and shapes for face-framing brows in seconds,” Glossier shares. It does come in a wider range of colors, but as these real people can attest, it works just as well as a $5 tube. And while it really is based on personal preference and experience when it comes to the makeup you use or like, it’s always nice to hear about less expensive options that work just as well as the high-end ones.

Everybody’s skin is different, so these WetnWild and e.l.f.

’s products may work better for some people than others, but who doesn’t like an underdog? Up Next: Related: The ‘Completely False’ Beauty Rule a Makeup Artist Is Begging Women Over 50 to Toss Out.