1 week Ago
A University of New Hampshire Survey Center poll done by a national political action committee for libraries and MomsRising Together found most Granite State residents opposed a pending bill to make educators subject to criminal prosecution under state obscenity laws. The same poll found strong support (59% for, 19% opposed) for disciplining teachers who “knowingly” provided harmful materials to students and for having a complaint process (66% for, 29% opposed) for parents to object to their children having access to specific books or materials. John Chrastka is executive director of EveryLibrary, which partnered in the poll.
"The poll numbers are clear. New Hampshire voters do not want to see a bill that would criminalize educators, school boards, and school librarians as education policy,” Chrastka said. “Voters don't like Concord telling local schools what students can read and how parents can parent.
States like Indiana and Oklahoma have put criminalization provisions in place, and it's not building better schools there.” The Senate Education Committee will hold likely the last public hearing for the House-approved bill ( HB 324 ) this Thursday. Along partisan lines, the House late last month approved the bill, 193-148 , with only three Republicans joining all but one Democrat in opposition.
Rep. Glenn Cordelli, R-Tuftonboro, said he worked with Attorney General John Formella’s office on how to close a loophole since education was exempt from the state’s obscenity laws. “It is our duty to protect minor children,” said Cordelli, who chairs the new House Education Policy and Administration Committee.
“This bill is about materials that are harmful to minor children in schools and the ability for parents to object to them.” During its first public hearing last February signed up in support while 1,355 opposed it. “Our attorney general feels that it would be only the most extreme case for a criminal case to be opened for K-12 education, but that option should be available in such a case,” Cordelli said in written testimony to the House.
The total of 1,372 completed the survey for UNH along with 62 respondents who were recruited via text message from March 20-24. The margin of error for the poll was plus or minus 2.6%.
On criminal prosecution, 36% said they could oppose that provision, 52% opposed it, 7% were neutral and 5% didn’t have an answer. Politically, certain circles support giving parents more of a say in what their children are exposed to in public schools. Last December, outgoing Gov.
Chris Sununu had to withdraw his pick to fill the vacant post of state librarian because the candidate, Assistant Librarian Mindy Atwood, had spoken at conferences about how library advocates should work to defeat proposed book bans. A clear majority on the GOP-led Executive Council told Sununu his pick of Atwood was dead on arrival for this reason. During House debate, Rep.
Peggy Balboni, D-Nashua, pointed out state law already allows parents to review all instructional materials. "But while parents can decide what materials their child can access, they do not have the right to determine which materials are available for other students; that is censorship," Balboni said. MacKenzie Nicholson is senior director for MomsRising Together & MomsRising Education Fund.
“Parents in the Granite State aren’t asking for this. HB 324 is an extreme bill that goes too far and opens the door to criminalizing teachers and school librarians for doing their jobs,” Nicholson said. “The Senate should table this bill and come back to the issue with a more thoughtful, balanced approach that actually reflects the values of families in the Live Free or Die state.
” Asked how such a law would affect teacher recruitment, 55% told the poll this would make it harder, 9% said it would be easier, 29% said this will have little effect and 7% don’t know. The poll also found if Gov. Kelly Ayotte signed the bill, a moderate plurality (41%) said they would be less likely to vote for her in 2026 compared with those who said it would make them more likely (30%) to support her.
The third-largest group (24%) said it would make little or no difference and 5% did not know. [email protected].
